So I finally did succumb to spending the money to buy an iPhone 3G before it got to the free with contract price.
iPhone does not really need a dated review from me, especially given the fact I did not have other 3G WinMo phones to compare against. I do enjoy very much the touchscreen and the exchange integration. It is a very good email checking machine if not a great email replying machine. Browsing is definitely better than my older smaller phone though it might not be much different than newer big screen phones.
But, boy do I have have gripes with the RDF promulgated by the Apple folks!
People complain a lot about Windows and Microsoft products. I give Microsoft a lot of rope since they have to write software that runs on a lot of other peoples hardware (and the peripherals). When you tightly control the hardware and the platform it is a lot easier to control the complete user experience.
I have had more issues with the iPhone than I have had with my refurbished AudioVox 5600 WinMo (maybe I use more things on it). The apps do crash on the iPhone all the time. However, there is no BSOD to blame Apple, but a convenient recovery back to the Home Screen to hide what happened. It is as if nothing happened at all. No popup, no information, no log. And it has happened with Apple apps rather than only with installed apps from the store. If that is not RDF, I am not sure what is. I do have to admit that at least the underlying OS has only crashed or frozen rarely. I appreciate the unix underpinnings with a wonderful GUI on top.
The hardware does not speak to pristine quality control either. The mute button stopped muting and I had to get an appointment at an apple store to get a replacement phone. I never managed to get a walk-in appointment at the apple store and finally did have to make an appointment online before I went to the store. I guess the faithful needed to drink from the fountain frequently.
I frequently email Jelena and the Mail application always corrects it to Helena and sometimes I forget to fix the name. I tried to figure out if I could somehow edit the database but hey Apple knows what is good for you better than yourself.
Some annoyances are standard Apple fare than iPhone specific. If I have non-DRM mp3s I rip or buy from Amazon (I recommend Countdown Kids for $0.99 when on sale) or elsewhere, I expect to be able to sync it to iPhone and get them to my work computer (okay not the Countdown Kids). Of course, you cannot really get the songs off the phone using iTunes OS. Hey, Apple is kind enough to let you play them from the iphone when it is connected anywhere, but whoa, whoa … what do mean copy to a second machine from iphone (remember … non-DRM songs). Why would the sheeple want it? They can just buy the song again from iTunes on the second computer! (For the record simply use Media Monkey and it lets you drag and drop from iPhone to the windows folder).
When companies make nice products that people want to buy, it gets frustrating when you cannot use them fully the way you want them rather than the way the manufacturer intended you to. I think for people like me who are hands-on, the cheaper less refined products are better than well-crafted, tight-controlled Apple products. I think for people who like Plug and Use but no Play, Apple products work well. I love my Popcorn Hour if it says anything about me. I think the iPhone reinforced a thought I heard somewhere: Mac owners are rich or dumb or both.